Why I asked for my money back on the FAI Fix

The FAI Fix was recommended to me by a friend of a friend. It was developed by two Personal Trainers (PTs) in the USA – Shane and Matt – who both had significant hip issues and manage to overcome pain, impingement and poor Range of Movement (RoM) without surgery – although they do admit that this has taken up to a decade of daily work! It comes with a number of success stories on the website: https://www.thefaifix.com/ and is supported by some really excellent YouTube videos and emails that made me really feel that Shane and Matt understood the issues and challenges of hip pain, and also explained the anatomy aspects of it really clearly.

However, when I was thinking about signing up for the programme I could not find any impartial reviews of how people had got on with the programme. And I saw tweets and messages of others looking for the same. So I thought that I would write about my experiences in order to support others.

The programme

There are 2 levels of the programme. The basic one is the FAI Fix Basic for $129.95 USD – a one-off payment that then gives ongoing access to the exercise library. There is then a further payment to do the more advanced programme for athletes who want more hip movement (eg powerlifters). But they are clear that this is a much smaller group, and is a progression from the first programme once you have resolved the pain in your hips in usual daily activities.

On the homepage, they explain their TSR system – Tissue Work, Stretching and Reactivation. This is a common (and well-proven) structure for many rehab programmes:

  1. releases with the foam roller, ball, knobbler etc to release the overactive muscles
  2. stretching to lengthen the tight muscles
  3. reactivation to activate and strengthen the underactive muscles

It is impressive how much more RoM you can get by doing targeted muscle releases before stretching that area.

There are a minimum number of tools that you need in order to be able to follow the programme – a foam roller, a strap (which could be a belt from a dressing gown), a lacrosse ball (or small, hard ball – there are different levels of hardness in therapy balls and the idea is that you progress) and possibly a ‘knobbler’:

The tools! The ‘stick’ was an optional extra, and the blue one is the ‘knobbler’ – but most of the programme could be done on the floor in front of a mirror with the foam roller.

When the programme link arrives there are 13 tests which are meant to narrow down which of the 5 key muscle groups is the issue. Then there is a TSR exercise set for each muscle group and a 6th workout that is a combination across muscle groups.

My experience with the programme

In advance of signing up for the programme, I was uncertain whether it was suitable for me given that I was 6 months on from hip arthroscopy surgery. However, I got a response that looked like it was a response from one of the 2 PTs reassuring me that it would be suitable – although looking back, I now think that it was probably compiled from a series of standard paragraphs.

Working through the programme is quite intense – the diagnostic exercises take quite a lot of set up and checking the form and RoM in front of the mirror. If you or someone in your family are not quite experienced in Personal Training and muscle groups it would be quite difficult to work through. And the challenge for me was that the tests were not discerning for me – all of them were painful and all of them had less-than-ideal RoM, so it was hard to diagnose where to focus.

I diligently followed the programme daily for 4 weeks. The good news is that I did see an increase in my RoM, but no reduction in the pain before, during or after the exercises. Therefore, I followed the process to get advice from Shane and Matt. I wrote a summary of how I had interpreted the 13 tests and what I had been doing, but got only a 2-line response from someone other than them telling me that I needed to choose just one muscle group and focus on that, but no further details on how to make that choice or how to better understand the diagnostic tests (given that all were painful and low RoM).

I followed the advice for another 4 weeks and then got in touch again, but did not get any response this time. In the meantime, the general emails from them changed. In the first couple of weeks, they had been bits of advice and case studies which were definitely motivational – especially on fixing the body through movement rather than surgery. But after that, the emails continued to come 3-4 times per week, but were now trying to sell more stuff (tools, personal coaching, other programmes etc). 

So, I decided to ask for my money back (which in-line with their no-quibble money-back guarantee they refunded immediately – although interestingly they did not ask for any feedback on what had worked and not worked, or why I was asking for my money back).

My summary

The exercise video library is good (there are probably 50 exercise variants covering the 5 muscle groups), but I would suggest that the money is much better spent with a Movement Trainer who specializes in Corrective Exercise and can really help you to diagnose which are the problem movements and then focus a personalised programme on just what you need. This should actually start to address where you have the pain and monitor development and progress you see with the exercises, in order to then make choices on how to progress.

That said, the overall message that you can make progress on your hip pain without surgery is profoundly supportive. Plus there is a strong sense of realism in the sense that they are clear that it will take work and time.

Good luck with getting to the bottom of your hip pain and finding the key to unlocking the pain.

My experience with hydrotherapy

I have not blogged for a while whilst I have been trying new things, doing lots of research and trying to make progress on reducing my pain and increasing my ability to cope with day-to-day tasks and activities. It has been an interesting voyage where I have become clearer that there are many paths to recovery – and no-one has the universal answer, so you have to try lots of things! With this in mind, I thought that I would share in a few blogs over the coming weeks some of my recent experiences.

Hydrotherapy was one of the things that was suggested after each of my surgeries. It is 45 mins drive to the nearest hydrotherapy pools and there are none in my local authority area. Plus you have to have a medical referral form and go through some extra checks to get access, so it all took a bit of organising. But I think that is was well worth it, as I think that it reduced pain in the short-term and had an incremental improvement in the Range of Movement (RoM) in the scar tissue and the affected muscles.

What is hydrotherapy?

The hydrotherapy pool is kept at 37 degrees Celsius, which consistently feels very pleasant and after 30 mins of doing structured exercises feels positively hot!

It is about shoulder depth and about 10m across, so it is easy to get the benefit of the water resistance as well as the immersion.  There is also easy access, including a hoist so that you can get in and out even when your body is not working well. Given that there is only space for a small number of people, it is key to reserve the slot and be there changed and ready in time.

You can work with a physio in the session, but once you have a routine it is relatively easy to work through the exercises on your own. There are ‘weights’ made from floats to create additional resistance by pushing them down in the water and inflatable ‘noodles’ for support.

How is it better than a normal pool or hot tub?

I had tried both the normal pool and hot-tub, and would say that the hydrotherapy pool is much better.

Doing my exercises in the pool was hard work (remember that 1 litre of water is 1kg – so there is lots of weight in the water resistance), and the cooler water temperature that makes it suitable for swimming means that there is not the therapeutic benefit of the muscle release that helps with RoM and probably with the pain reduction too.

I had also used the pool to try a little aqua-jogging with the float-belt (as shown in the photo). This is used a lot by elite athletes when they have injuries and it is claimed that you can keep 80% of your running fitness if you put the same hours in at the pool. This should work really well for lower limb injuries where you need to keep the muscle memory, but avoid the impact (especially in stress fractures and some soft-tissue overuse injuries). But given that for me the inflammation affects the movement pattern, I found that it was too tough at this stage.  

The aquajogging float belt clips around you to keep you upright without your feet touching the bottom of the pool (you need a pool deep enough for this!) and you can add difficulty by holding a waterbottle in each hand and changing the amount of liquid in it for more difficulty.

The hot tub is useful for me for the muscle release and for managing some of the pain. But it is not deep enough or large enough to do all of the exercises, so it is not as good as the hydrotherapy pool. I think also that the 30 mins slot, where everyone else is also working on their exercises, brings a level of focus that really helps.

Did it make any difference?

My own experience was that it was a very supportive environment – everyone there is working on getting better and is very willing to share what they have had success with.

In terms of the physical impact, the warmth definitely had a positive impact in terms of reducing pain for a few hours (just like hot water bottles etc when at home). My understanding is that this is not universal – some people find that the pain is reduced with cold, others with warmth.

Plus, I found that 30 mins of hydrotherapy definitely improved RoM for a period of 24-48 hours and if I did it 3 times per week, I saw real progress on my land-based exercises. That said, it was positively hard work – after 30 mins the combination of the temperature and the hard work was very tiring and I was keen to get out and have a nice drink of water! And the travel on top made it quite a bit harder. So, I would say that if you have a hydrotherapy pool nearby, do make use of it in your recovery and rehabilitation.

The skinny on scar tissue

Scar tissue sounds like one of those things that you can do very little about. But actually it is a little more complex than that!

Scar tissue is laid down in the key ‘proliferative’ phase of healing and then remodels during the maturation phase of healing. If you want to read more on this, read my blog ‘How do you heal after invasive surgery?’ http://www.injuredathlete.co.uk/how-do-you-heal-after-invasive-surgery/

This image is my simple visualisation of the haphazard scar tissue on the left, and then how it settles into the correct structure after remodelling on the right. This gives a sense of why the scar tissue feels tight, solid and lacks the usual movement and elasticity of the remodelled tissue on the right.

A simple demonstration symbolising the multi-directional aspect of scar tissue on the left, and the linear nature of remodelled tissue on the right.

But not everyone lays down scar tissue in the same way!

It transpires that different people lay down scar tissue in different ways, and therefore can get more complications from the adhesions and slower remodelling.

How can you know if you are one of those people?

It is probably difficult to know, if you have never had any surgery before, but a couple of signs that would be worth looking at are:

  • Do you still have lots of scars from cuts and grazes from your childhood? Or have these faded away now?
  • When you have had cuts or grazes over the last few years, has the mark (both in texture and colouring) lingered for a year or more?
  • And if you have had surgery, did the scar fade to an almost invisible light white line within 6 months or linger on?

If you are on the longer ranges, you could be someone who lays down stickier scar tissue and takes longer for it to remodel into the usual tissue, with usual movement and function.

What can you do about this before surgery?

If you already suspect this before your surgery, do talk over with the surgeon your previous healing and the types of movement and sport that you want to be able to return to. The choices that they make can really change your scar tissue – and counterintuitively, sometimes a larger scar can mean less scar tissue.

And if you are having keyhole (or arthroscopic) surgery, so not underestimate the scar tissue. If you can imagine, it is like a sticky rope of scar tissue that goes from the point of entry to the point of surgery. And that can be quite a distance. In areas like the hop there are lots of different muscles, tendons, ligaments and bone for it to stick to and in the abdomen there are also organs.

Straight after the surgery

As soon as the surgery is complete, the surgeon and physiotherapists will often get you moving through as much of the range of movement as you can. This is to gently tear the sticky scar tissue off things that it should not be sticking to and is especially important with joint mobility.

As soon as the wound has sealed up, there are four things that you can do to help the scar tissue to start to remodel:

  1. Massage it for 5 minutes at a time, using your finger tips and moving in all directions with as much pressure as feels comfortable. Remember that the surgery will have cut through 7 different layers of tissue and they each need to remodel.
  2. Rub in some Vitamin-E based oil, such as Bio Oil to help the process
  3. Protect it with a high factor sun protection cream if you are going out in sunshine, as it will burn really easily and this will damage the healing (as well as discolouring it)
  4. Keep drinking lots of water and eating a good high protein diet, so that there is lots of collagen for the body to call on. There are mixed views on whether a collagen supplement help, or whether a diet with things like oily fish and chicken broth are sufficient.

Through the next phases of healing, gentle movement through the range of movement (with no weight or resistance) will be key in order to get the sticky fibres to only stick in the right place! If you start to get into a lot of pain, you should be:

  • Talking with your physiotherapist and surgeon about the risk of unwanted adhesions and sharing what pain you have at different parts of the range of movement.
  • Showing them your scar – especially if you feel that it is too raised up from the surface of the skin, or too indented.

Best of luck – do not be despondent if you are someone who lays down scar tissue differently. The body is an amazing thing, and it will do the remodelling. It may just take a little more time, and that may mean a longer recovery phase for you and sadly more pain for a while, plus needing to keep focusing on range of movement for a little longer before you progress back to your activities and sports.

How do musculoskeletal injuries heal?

Following my blog on how the body heals from invasive surgery (http://www.injuredathlete.co.uk/how-do-you-heal-after-invasive-surgery/) , I thought that it would be useful to do the same for musculoskeletal issues, since these are common injuries for athletes. This is a really huge topic, and I have struggled to get down the most relevant parts into something that I think may be useful for injured athletes and coaches to understand what questions they will ask of the medical team treating them. I have not covered musculoskeletal diseases such as osteoarthritis, carpal tunnel syndrome, tendonitis etc (many of which qualify as a disability under Social Security, if the symptoms reach a certain level of severity), as these are much more complex and long-lasting.

The challenge of most of musculoskeletal injuries is that they generally involve tendons (which connect bones to muscles), ligaments (which connect bone to bone) and/or cartilage (the soft, gel-like tissue that provides cushioning and enables movement in joints). The white colour of these tissue types give a clue to the fact that they do not have their own blood supply. This means that they heal much more slowly than damaged skin or muscles (which have their own blood supply). The surgical view is that they do not regenerate and this is why often surgery is offered – mending torn tendons and ligaments and replacing ruptured ones.

You need to play an active role in healing musculoskeletal injuries

Whilst the fundamental phases of healing are the same as a cut or muscle tear, there are a couple of key differences that you need to act on:

  1. the pain signals through the healing phases are very different and you need to actively manage your way through this – at times managing the pain to protect the healing of the correct Range of Movement for your body. It seems counter-intuitive not to listen to the pain in your body, but this is the reason.
  2. you do need to actively rehabilitate the area through each of the 3 stages, as it is unlikely to heal correctly without your active focus and support: initially using the ‘POLICE’ protocol (see below) and then with range of movement for that joint and then specific strengthening of that area. When you are in a lot of pain, the constant health professional exhortations of ‘keep moving’ may not seem to be very helpful, but this is the reason why.
  3. this is a long-term game, and you can expect to need to focus on this for a period of 12 to 24 months. But for those who stay the course and do the right things, the results do come.

Stage 1 of musculoskeletal healing – Inflammation.

The swelling and redness may be hidden inside the joint, but the symptoms will be such that no time day or night is pain-free and you may be able to detect the heat coming from the joint, as well as the tenderness, pain and loss of range of movement. If rest or a change of position gives relief, then the healing has progressed to the repair stage. The inflammation stage generally lasts 3-5 days, but can last a lot longer and if you re-injure or re-inflame the same area, then you go back into this stage.

The point of this stage for the body is protecting the area with swelling whilst it lays the foundations for the healing – clearing out the damaged cells and starting to spin webs of protective tissue that bind the wound together and stop the flow of liquids through the area.

This is the stage that you really need to apply the ‘POLICE’ protocol. This has replaced the old ‘RICE’ protocol (see the table below). So that in the past, the recommendation was Rest, get an Ice pack on the area, use Compression and Elevate the limb. All of these are designed to reduce the inflammation and allow the body to get through this first stage. Interestingly, anti-inflammatory medications do reduce the inflammation, but interfere with the body’s natural management of inflammation – so as soon as you are out of the immediate pain it is best to stop taking these in order to encourage the cellular-level healing process to begin.

The new ‘POLICE’ protocol reflects the fact that the latest medical studies suggest that some movement is good, even at these early stages. So ‘Protect ‘the joint from the bad motion that has caused the injury (eg twisting), with support, splinting or bracing as needed. Then work to get ‘Optimum Loading’ – moving the joint through the range of movement in every-day activities, but not causing additional pain. This is why we see increasing numbers of people in protective boots and slings, instead of full plaster-casts. The view on ‘Icing’ has also developed – and the guidance is that you should not apply it for longer than 10 minutes and more than 3 times per day (as too much icing can also damage the tissues).

P = Protect
OL = Optimum Loading
R = Rest
I = Ice I = Ice
C = Compression C = Compression
E = Elevation E = Elevation

Stage 2 of musculoskeletal healing – Repair or Proliferation.

During this stage the body develops the new tissue, initially haphazardly and then starting to align these cells correctly. This stage usually starts from a week after the injury and lasts 6-12 weeks or longer. Pain usually comes and goes, according to the position or movement of the body. If pain or fear of pain inhibits movement in this stage, then the pattern with which the scar tissue is laid down can inhibit movement significantly and reduce your body’s ability to function. Failure to stretch and move at this time will lead to weak, but tight muscles that are intermittently painful and vulnerable to re-injury. Therefore you really need to consistently (and gently) put the body through a normal range of movement and the unhelpful cross-fibres will be broken and the useful fibres that support the usual range of movement will be strengthened.  If this repair stage does not lead to correct healing, the danger is that the body will start to develop workarounds and compensating movements, which can lead to aches and injuries elsewhere as the body moves into the third stage of healing with the wrong fundamental structure in the injury area.

Stage 3 of musculoskeletal healing – Remodelling or Maturation.

In this stage the tissues build their flexibility and strength, and this lasts at least 6 months and can be two years or more. Even now, you may get some pain with certain movements (especially when you take the movement to the end-zones of the Range of Movement – which you do need to do), or you may be pain-free. This is why usually from around 4-12 weeks after injury (depending on the injury: follow your surgeon’s or physio’s advice), you should be adding in some strength-based training – starting very gently and slowly building up to 3 sets of 10 repetitions (working to failure), with a day or two of rest between sessions for the body to recover and rebuild (in line with the progressive overload model of development) and obviously backing off if the level of pain increases.

If you do not keep rehabbing the area, there is a very strong probability of significantly reinjuring it because it is so far below strength. This is very challenging, as it is usually just one or two exercises that you need to do over and over again, gently progressing them. And before you have done this, it may well be too premature to go back to a repetitive loading activity like running, or even cycling. Many people do not have the patience to do this progressive strengthening over the period of 12-24 months that it takes, and this is one of the reasons why re-injury is common. Even with the correct rehab, the area often stays 20% weaker than before the injury.  Hence you will need to keep looking at your form to check that there are not compensation behaviours that will cause other injuries, and look at your activities to check that you are giving it the protection that it needs.

Why pain makes this all so much harder

The challenge for many people in chronic pain* is that the correct level of managing the inflammation, mobilising the joint to get the range of movement and strength building across the 3 phases is hard to do. The pain makes them avoid exercise and stretching required for correct healing. At times the level of incorrect healing in stage 2 can need significant manipulation (even under general anaesthetic) to break up the adhesion and re-stimulate inflammation. You then effectively start back at phase 1 of healing, and need to ensure that stretching (for Range of Movement) and exercise (to stimulate the limited blood supply to the area) then begin the process of rehabilitation.

As well as medications, guided corticosteroid injections into the area are common and can bring very significant short-term relief. You need to make the decision on these with your Orthopaedic Consultant. The only anecdote that I would pass on is one where an athlete had a number of injections into the tendon over a 2-year period, and the tendon did rupture. One of the questions was whether the perforations from the multiple injections had played a role.

* The definition of chronic pain varies, but it is long-term pain and most seem to define it as having lasted for over 3 months or over 6 months. I think that the key definition is having been in pain for that length of time, you get to the stage where you adapt your physical, mental and emotional approaches to life (whether consciously or unconsciously) as a consequence of the pain. As well as these external impacts on your life, the internal impacts of your body swimming in the chemicals associated with inflammation and the nerve pain patterns can also have significant impacts on your healing.